Sync any folder to SkyDrive – Reloaded

[UPDATE: A new release with version number 1.2.1 is available http://ssx.codeplex.com/releases/view/101941]

The first release of SkyShellEx was an attempt to add on a sorely missed  feature in the SkyDrive desktop app for Windows. The ability to sync any folder on your disk to the cloud was one main differentiator of Live Mesh (R.I.P. 13th Feb 2013) over competitors like DropBox or GDrive. When I was quickly putting together a shell extension that could create folder junction in NTFS, I was hoping it would help out a few people. However, I was surprised by the traffic and feedback I got for my little hack. Thanks everybody for your nice comments and appreciation! Realizing that there is high demand for keeping existing folders structures intact but still taking advantage of cloud storage, I decided to implement a successor that eliminates issues of the old version and adds few new features. The result of this work , SkyShellEx 1.2, is now available at http://ssx.codeplex.com/ Grab the bits as long as they are fresh. I also would like to give a special Thanks to my old friend and awesome developer Danny Tomuschat. This release of SkyShellEx wouldn’t have been possible without his work.

[DISCALIMER: SkyShellEx, whether in the form of source code or executable, is provided As Is. There is no warranty that the software is appropriate for any specific use. While it is believed to be correct, there is no guarantee that the code does not contain either general errors or errors that my occur under specific combination of parameters or use. The practice of keeping regular backups of your data is strongly recommended.]

We will move your data and why it’s better

While the original SkyShellEx had only little impact on your file structure,  the new version will actually migrate your data into SkyDrive. However, like in the old version, your folder structure will be maintained. Only this time, the folder junction will be created as a surrogate at the original folder location. If moving your data is a big no-no for you then you have three options right now. First, you can stick with the old version of SkyShellEx and live with its shortcomings. Second, you keep reading and hopefully I can convince you why it’s better this way. Third, you can try to convince me to bring it back the old way as an option for a future version.

Syncing actually works now

Folder junctions created in the SkyDrive folder do sync when the junction is created. However, a lot of users, including me, reported that changes in the folder were not synced by SkyDrive. The only workaround was to restart SkyDrive or to create and delete a dummy file somewhere in SkyDrive in order to trigger a sync. Moving the actual folder into SkyDrive will circumvent this kind of issues.  Your files will be always fresh and up to date.

Enabling Device to Device Sync

Having real folders in SkyDrive also enables a scenario that wasn’t easily possible with folder junction. Let’s assume you have two or more PC’s and you want to sync your Music folder across all PC’s. While you could create the folder junction in SkyDrive for the first PC, you couldn’t do the same on any of the other PC’s. The junction just couldn’t be created because the folder Music already existed in SkyDrive. Now you have the possibility to exactly do this. Just to be clear this is NOT the peer to peer sync you know from Live Mesh. The sync always happens via the SkyDrive folder in the cloud. You have the choice to merge folders from different PC’s or to sync them side by side. More details below.

How it works

Since you still reading and not deterred by the fact that SkyShellEx moves your data around, lets talk about new features. Once installed, this release of SkyShellEx works in principle the same way as the previous one. Just right click on any folder on your disk and you will see a new context menu entry called Sync to SkyDrive. Well, actually not for any folder. We are actively preventing syncs of folders that live under Windows, System or Programs as well as folder from removable storage. If you can give me a good reason to allow you to mess with your system files then let me know. SkyShellEx is using a new icon with the right dimensions now.

If you click on the menu item “Sync to SkyDrive” and the selected folder doesn’t exist in SkyDrive then the folder will be silently moved and a surrogate folder in form of an folder junction will be placed at the original location. In case SkyDrive already contains a folder with the same name, we support two scenarios that will be handled by the following dialog.

In the first scenario “Merged folders” we assume that the folder is synced by SkyDrive from another PC and you want to sync the same folder with the current PC. If you select this option, your existing folder will be merged and again, the original folder will be replaced by a folder junction. The second scenario “Side by side” covers two cases. Like in the first scenario it could be a folder from another device, but this time you would rather have two versions of the same folder side by side. I In the subsequent dialog a new name with computer name  as a suffix is suggested or you can choose your own name.

The second use case covers the possibility that two folder with he same name live in different places on your disk. If you currently already sync a folder on your computer with the same name then SkyShellEx will suggest a new name that includes the parent folder name as a prefix or you can choose your own name

Once a folder is synced via SkyShellEx, folder in SkyDrive as well as the junction gets a new icon. This allows you do identify more easily your synced folders. You will recognize that the new icon will show right away or not. Depending on the weather. moon phase or any other unrelated event, Explorer decides to show the icon sooner or later. If anybody knows how to force Explorer to always show the changed icon immediately then ping me. I will owe you.

In case you don’t want to sync your folder anymore and want your folder back as it was, just right click the folder or the junction and you will see a menu entry called “Stop syncing to SkyDrive”.

This will bring up a dialog that offers two options. The first one restores your folder at is original place but leaves a copy of your data in SkyDrive. This prevents that data get deleted from other machines that also sync the same folder. The second option also restores your original folder but removes it completely from SkyDrive. Be aware that the data wont be available for any other devices anymore.

Sharing folders

Sharing folders was another missing feature in the original release of SkyDrive. Also it is available now and we providing kind of redundant functionality here, I’m not a big fan on how SkyDrive is implementing sharing. Just opening a browser window looks kind of cheap to me. Well, we also using the web UI but we tried do it in a more elegant way, so it feels integrated with the Desktop. If you do your first sync you will be asked to trust us and give SkyShellEx access to your SkyDrive. Actually we just need this permission to resolve the local folder name to the folder ID used by SkyDrive. If you don’t want to answer this question every time then don’t forget to set the check mark on the “Remember access for SkyShellEx” option.

Once the folder name is resolved, you will see the familiar sharing screen from SkyDrive with all it’s options. We tried our best to hook into all the HTML events, so the Web UI behaves like a native window. We also worked on our own sharing solution via the Live SDK but soon we realized that the exposed API is to limited compared to the Web UI.

That’s SkyShellEx 1.2 and I hope it will be useful you. Give us your feedback and bug reports on CodePlex http://ssx.codeplex.com/

Race2Surface

 

[Update 2 ]

The promotion is over. Check out my other promotion WriteOneGetOne

 

[Update]

Race2Surface has started. Here the leaderboard:

Developer	Number of Apps	Points
Dev1	6	12
G4MB10R	2	2
DYY	3	4
vivanov	4	7
yamspog	3	7
RAMP	1	1
Total	19

 

I’m back with an even more exciting promotion. After the great success of Phones4Apps, I’m spicing things up a little bit. Since Windows Phone is as awesome as Windows 8, you should develop for both platforms and you should own the best devices for both platforms. That’s why I’m giving away brand new shiny Nokia Lumia 800/900 and one Surface 64GB with touch cover as Grand Prize. Here the facts:

• The promotions starts January 1st 2013 and ends March 1st 2013
• For each app you submit you get points that count for the Grand Prize.
• The developer with the most points at the end of the promotion gets the Surface. (In case of a draw the submission date counts)
• The Grand Prize is only given if a total of 30 apps are submitted by March 1st, 2013.
• If you submit 2 apps you get a Lumia 800
• If you submit 4 apps you get a Lumia 900 (4 devices available – First-come, First-served)
• A leader board (anonymous if wished) will be posted as the apps coming in.

Some rules:

1) You must be a resident of British Columbia, Alberta, Saskatchewan, Washington* or Oregon*

*Developer in US have to pay shipping and import fees for your prize.

2) The app must be submitted after November 1, 2012 to the Marketplace and must not submitted to any of my previous promotions.

3) Only one phone per developer.

4) The app must be a QUALITY app… What does that mean?  It means:

a) Must pass Marketplace Certification,

b) No Hello World, Picture Catalog / Resizer or Flashlight apps.

c) No more than 1 of your apps can be an RSS Reader

d) No multiple variants on a theme (travel/tourism, etc.)

e) The app must have a useful function.

5) You must be a member of DVLUP and your apps must be visible within DVLUP. (Ask me for registration codes.)

6) All Apps will be assessed by me and my decisions regarding validity in this promotion are final.

• 1 point for any app or game
• 2 points if it’s your very first app in the market (newbie reward)
• 2 points for each D3D or XNA game with multiple levels and game stats
• 3 points for each app that is available for Windows 8 as well
• 3 points for each app that is a companion app for a Windows 8 app

7) This promotion is being held by me, without any express written or implied consent or participation from any third party.

8) By submitting your apps to me for evaluation, you agree to hold me not responsible for any promotion, remuneration or other, expectations whether implied or inferred.  I am doing this to help developers, not looking for any problems.

9) The winners will be chosen by me.

How to Submit an App:

As soon as your app is in the marketplace, email me the deep link to your app to nokiaguy@outlook.com. Keep in mind that the quality of your app counts. Let’s start folks it’s a race!

Don’t forget that you can get submit you apps in DVLUP and the Developer Movement as well.

Sync any folder to SkyDrive

[Update: A new version of SkyShellEx is available. Read more about it here: http://janhannemann.wordpress.com/2013/02/13/sync-any-folder-to-skydrive-reloaded/]

With the arrival of the new SkyDrive app we are finally able to take advantage of the 25GB online storage. The new app https://apps.live.com/skydrive allows you to sync a specific folder to your online storage like Dropbox. It is very simple; just drop whatever you want into the SkyDrive folder and it’s up to the cloud. But it also comes with the same limitations like Dropbox. If you are a Live Mesh user then you probably appreciate that you can sync any folder on your hard drive to the cloud not matter where it is located. This is a very nice feature because it allows you to keep your existing folder structure. For some reason this feature didn’t make it into the SkyDrive app and Live Mesh will be discontinued soon.

NTFS to the rescue

Fortunately NTFS has some nice features that we barely use but can be very useful. One of them is symbolic links or folder junctions. Basically it allows you to mount a folder into another folder, so it looks like the folder is physically located there. So my thought was – if the Explorer can’t see it then SkyDrive can’t see it and will handle them as regular folders. The command to create such a link is:

MKLINK [[/D] | [/H] | [/J]] Link Target.

The /D parameter creates a symbolic directory link and it was my first try because they are recommended over directory junctions /J but SkyDrive crashed with symbolic links while directory junctions worked with no problems. Plus, we don’t need admin rights to create junctions. If you execute the command then a junction will be created that like a folder and SkyDrive starts syncing its content.

SkyShellEx

While the command line just works fine I wanted a more convenient way to sync my folders; a perfect match for a shell extension. So I spent a couple of hours on implementing a little helper that can be downloaded as 64 bit version here SkyShellEx_x64 and 32 bit version here SkyShellEx_x32 If you want to have a look at the source code first then you can find it here SkyShellEx_Project.

[Update: the original version has a bug that prevents syncing of folders that have one or more spaces in there full path. The version 1.01 fixes that problem. SkyShellEx_x64_1.01, SkyShellEx_x32_1.01, SkyShellEx_Project_1.01 You have to reboot to apply the changes.]

After installing the extension you will see one of two possible menu items when you right click a folder. The first one starts syncing a folder and shows up on any folder except ones that are already in the SkyDrive folder. The second menu stops the syncing of a folder and shows up on any ones that are already in the SkyDrive folder and is a directory junction. See screenshot below.

      

Limitations

I found the shell extension very useful but it has some limitations. Currently I can’t detect whether a folder is already syncing to SkyDrive. So you won’t see the “Stop Sync to Skydrive” menu but the “Sync to Skydrive” when you at the physical location of a folder that has already a junction to SkyDrive. It’s no problem to execute the command again but it’s confusing. It would be also useful to have an icon overlay on folders that sync to SkyDrive. If there is enough interest I would try to improve the tool but for now it works well enough for me.

Let’s go crazy – Cloud to Cloud Sync

You maybe get the same idea as I did when I played around with this and yes it works. You can sync folder between Dropbox and SkyDrive.

[Disclaimer: The approach presented in this blog post is not officially supported. My software is provided “as is," and you use the software at your own risk.]